What the
MCX-462U does for your CPU, the MCX-159 does for your northbridge chip.
Providing not only a quiet alternative to your stock cooling, but also
bringing with it much improved temperatures. It’s not as if this
shouldn’t come as a surprise, considering that the two products
are nearly identical, differing only in their overall length and width.
Add to that the fact that the MCX-159 is not limited to one platform,
allowing for both AMD and Intel owners to partake in the cooling goodness.
Now the
question that everybody’s probably asking “Is the price
really worth it? Are there any tangible benefits?” I’m not
sure if you can really boil the answer down to a simple Yes or No as
there are a lot of variables that can come into play that will vary
from machine to machine. In terms of tangible benefits, beyond the reduced
temperatures, I found no increased stability or higher overclocking
mark that could be hit from the use of the upgraded northbridge cooling.
As noted though, this could be attributed to the fact that I may be
at a limiting point of my hardware in terms of how far the CPU or memory
can be pushed. If you’ll remember, similar results were noted
on the Microcool Northbridge review. Does that mean that it’s
not worth it? That’s hard to say, in an environment where the
northbridge is passively cooled, i.e. no attached fan, and relies off
of airflow from the CPU heatsink, and then there is definitely a possibility
that it could benefit the user. As I said, its usefulness will vary
greatly dependant of the environment in which it is put to use.
With an
average price of around $35, depending on the kit type, one has to wonder
if that money would not be better spent on a CPU heatsink as there are
plenty of good choices in that price range. A lot of the cooling hardware
we review can be considered much more than the average consumer would
need, and that would be true. The budget minded consumer is likely going
to be making sure that the CPU is taken care of first and foremost;
things such as overclocking and the need for upgrading the cooling of
other components involved in the process would be mute. I personally,
being the hardware freak that I am, would have to say that it’s
worth the cost, but then I come from the mentality of thinking that
lower temperatures are always going to be a benefit, even if not directly
seen by the naked eye.
Overall,
I can’t really find anything bad to say about the product except
for the fact that mounting on the AMD platform can prove to be a slight
challenge when it comes to the tightening of the mini-nuts. In the same
regard as the Microcool kit, one other exception that may come in to
play is possible interference between the CPU and northbridge heatsinks
if the two socket areas sit too closely to one another. It should be
noted that on Intel installations, Swiftech recommends the removal of
the heatsink if the unit is going to be moved around, i.e. travel to
a LAN party, etc. to ensure that, should a mounting clamp come loose
from the motherboard, that no damage is caused due to a 238gram block
of copper being thrown around inside your computer. It’s a shame
that the Intel mounting isn’t similar to the AMD, or that manufacturers
don’t integrate a two hole method over the Intel reference design
of the four mounting rings.
All in
all, I’d have to say that the MCX-159 is another sound product
from a company who actually knows a thing or two about cooling and isn’t
afraid to walk the “path less traveled”.
Once again
I’d like to thank the folks at Swiftech for supplying us with
today’s review sample and for the quality they continue to put
into each product they make.